Vantage Point Vol. 2 Issue 5: A Newsletter on Non-Traditional Security
Vantage Point Vol. 2 Issue 5: A Newsletter on Non-Traditional Security
Issue Commentary by Pratyush Pran Sarma | Column on Cyber-Security by Meenakshi Rao | Human Rights Monitor by Ajithaa RN |
Book Review by N.T. Malavika
The fifth issue of Vantage Point continues its examination of non-traditional security challenges in India and Asia. This edition explores extradition and justice, cybersecurity funding, human rights violations through state-sponsored militias, and the geopolitical implications of Asia’s water crisis. Each article offers a unique lens on how governance, policy, and international cooperation shape the security landscape.
Extradition and Justice – A Cross-Border Cooperation on Non-Traditional Security Challenges
Pratyush Pran Sarma discusses the role of extradition in addressing organized crimes and terrorism. The article highlights the extradition of Tahawwur Rana, linked to the 26/11 Mumbai attacks, as a milestone in India-U.S. cooperation. Despite legal and diplomatic hurdles, the move reflects progress in cross-border justice. Strengthening legal frameworks and ensuring fair trials are key to making extradition more effective.
Budget 2025: Fuelling Cybersecurity with Funds, But Where Are the Tax Breaks?
Meenakshi Rao analyzes the Union Budget 2025’s increased allocation for cybersecurity, including ₹900 crore for the National Mission on Interdisciplinary Cyber-Physical Systems. While funding is robust, the lack of tax incentives for cybersecurity firms is a missed opportunity. The article calls for targeted tax reforms to stimulate innovation and growth in the sector, alongside government-led investment in digital defence.
Counter-Insurgency through State-Sponsored Militias – The Case of Salwa Judum
Ajithaa RN examines the controversial Salwa Judum movement in Chhattisgarh, created to counter Left-Wing Extremism. The militia was responsible for widespread human rights violations, including displacement, recruitment of minors, and suppression of dissent. The Supreme Court declared it unconstitutional in 2011, but the damage to Adivasi communities remains. The article underscores the dangers of state-sponsored militias and the importance of democratic governance.
Book Review: Water: Asia’s New Battleground by Brahma Chellaney
N.T. Malavika reviews Chellaney’s book, which explores Asia’s escalating water crisis and its geopolitical consequences. The book covers transboundary river politics, China’s control over Tibetan water sources, and India’s internal water disputes. Chellaney warns of potential water wars and advocates for sustainable management and diplomatic cooperation. The review positions water security as a critical issue for regional peace and stability.
